Satellites can see the poachers, but the law says may
A study of marine park rules finds that data to catch illegal fishing is often useless in court because the wording is soft.



Picture made for ABUREAU.
Seeing a boat break the rules is one thing. Being allowed to act on what you saw is another. A new study read the rules behind 9,740 marine protected zones across 119 national legal instruments in 15 countries and asked whether satellite and vessel-tracking data could back an enforcement case.
The answer is mostly no. Only 4% of zones refer to vessel monitoring or satellite systems, and 61% use discretionary language such as "may" or "should". The authors score the rules out of 100 and find a mean of 33 for zone rules. They estimate that clear, unconditional prohibitions with tracking duties would lift that to 76, with no new technology.
ABURA has already reported how satellite and GPS records together reveal fishing that neither shows alone. This study adds the other half: the picture only counts if the rule says it counts.
For people who own or use data, the lesson is plain. A data set is worth most where the rules let it be used as evidence. Check what a rule allows before you pay to collect the data.


